Why Do Men Overestimate Their Ability To Fight?
— Updated on 7 September 2023

Why Do Men Overestimate Their Ability To Fight?

— Updated on 7 September 2023
Garry Lu
WORDS BY
Garry Lu

An Idiot’s Take On Anthropology #1: Why Do Men Overestimate Their Ability To Fight?

While I myself am no anthropologist, given the chance, I’d happily posit the exact same claim in any academic forum dumb enough to accept me. Wherever you go in the world, there will invariably be a group of blokes arriving at the exact same conversation (often around an outdoor glass table of some kind).

It’s instigated by an all-too-casual, “I reckon I could take you easy,” followed by a whole lot of counterfactual shit talk. Before long, you have a textbook scenario of men overestimating their own ability to fight.

Now stop right there. I didn’t mention a name, but almost reflexively, you thought of a few key individuals in your life who fancies themselves a capable and “street tough” operator. Am I correct? And while the cosmetic traits of these operators may vary from group to group, they’ll generally sit on the same part of the bell curve.

Because there’s one unifying trait that levels them all on the same playing field: despite having never formally trained in any combat sport, martial art, or discipline, they’re ridiculously confident in their ability to handle themselves. If a physical confrontation were to ever arise, that is.

What I’m about to undertake is an investigation in the loosest sense of the term. If I were to hazard a guess, I’d say we’ll end up with 35% academic research, 65% piss-take, and 100% weeknight entertainment.

The anatomy of the “hard man”

I mentioned before that there’s a bell curve. As with any ethnographic study, there will be outliers and so forth. In general terms, however, there are trends we can examine that define the “hard man”:

  • Vaguely athletic but not quite in their prime
  • Alternatively, jacked but in a bulky powerlifter sense with zero cardio
  • Apparently grew up with/knows someone “hard” (as if that’s a qualification)
  • Will openly suggest growing up with/knowing someone “hard” has somehow made them “hard” by osmosis
  • Possesses a few anecdotal experiences where they allegedly bested someone in spectacular fashion (less than a handful of eyewitnesses will be able to corroborate their claim)
  • Will usually “activate” for combat with a beer in hand, almost always with a beer in hand
  • Will accept any challenge with a weird amount of enthusiasm (almost too much, as if they actually wanted to hurt their mates)

There are a few more punchlines we could have included; namely the presence of Oakley glasses, way too much amateur commentary during a UFC event on any given Sunday at the pub (“Stand ’em up!”), perhaps even a particular car of choice. But the characteristics listed above describe the archetype I’m referring to in broad strokes.

The beauty of the “hard man” is that they can come from virtually anywhere. They’re office workers, they’re tradies, they’re young fellas, they’re old fellas. Hell, sometimes they’re not even fellas. To paraphrase JAY-Z, women can be pimps “hard men” too. So if it’s not strictly physical, cultural, or socio-economic… what is it precisely that gives birth to the “hard man”?

The Dunning-Kruger effect

We’ve all heard the saying, the loudest one in the room is the weakest one. Maybe even, the loudest one in the room knows the least. Or throwing it back to the 4th-century philosophical homie, Lao Tzu, he who knows does not speak while he who speaks does not know. As it so happens, there’s actually some science behind the idioms/generalisms/proverbs, and it’s known as the Dunning-Kruger effect.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is basically a cognitive bias where people with low ability in an area or field believe this said ability to be far greater than the reality. This stems from an internal illusion. In the words of social psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger themselves, the miscalibration of the incompetent which stems from an error about the self.

Essentially, when we lack competency, we simply don’t know enough to accurately assess our skill. Hence the whole “illusion.” Interestingly enough, the inverse is true those with high ability. The miscalibration of the highly competent stems from an error regarding others, meaning they see where it can all go wrong with everyday people and manage their personal expectations to a greater extent.

With consideration of the Dunning-Kruger effect, the social model it asserts is quite compatible with the matter of combat and perceived combat prowess. The blokes that peacock and yammer on about what they’d do in a hypothetical situation likely pose a danger to themselves above all else.

Those who have trained and carry the weight of fight experience with them, on the other hand, don’t exactly jump at every opportunity to prove themselves. And it’s not just because of some martial arts zen or even being humbled by the fight experience (although it certainly doesn’t hurt). It’s because they know the risks involved to a far greater extent.

The dangers of lacking self-awareness

Spend an hour browsing all the street justice compilations online and one thing becomes painfully clear. When you let your ego do the walking and the talking, it often ends in a cameraman yelling “Worldstar!” and you, face down in your own blood, slumped on the curb, where nobody gives a fuck whether or not you’re breathing correctly.

A fight is inherently chaotic. I could go on about CTE, potential long term brain damage, nerve damage, paralysis, broken bones, chipped teeth… But I’m not going to do that. In fact, I’m not even going to use laymen as the principle example from this point forward, either. Let’s see what happens when the Dunning-Kruger effect goes wild, and so-called “masters” of non-practical or fake martial arts cop a dose of the hard reality to the face.

There’s a term in the realm of combat known as “bullshido” — a portmanteau of the words bushido (the code of the Samurai) and bullshit (self-explanatory). Bullshido encompasses the culture of fake martial art McDojos which function as nothing more than belt factory scams. They take your money, make you go through the entire pageantry of “ancient self-defence secrets,” and hand you a costume and a colourful belt under the thin veil of tradition; while also warning you that losing something as supposedly sacred as your belt will incur a $15.99 replacement fee (the sheer irony).

Consequently, this builds you up to be another deluded soul. You learn virtually nothing. The worst part is you pose a danger to yourself, thinking you could realistically do something if and when shit actually hits the fan.

In recent times, the modern combat scene has been more vigilant about sniffing out bullshido wherever it may be; outcasting the charlatans and cutting the parasites off at the stem. Below, I’ve handpicked a selection of very choice clips depicting when men overestimate their own ability to fight:

The crucial lesson to take away from everything you’ve just read? If you’ve ever been in a real fight, maybe you wouldn’t be so keen for another.

Be sure to check out the other three instalments of An Idiot’s Take On Anthropology:

  1. The Psychological Benefits Of Teasing Your Mates (According To Science)
  2. Why Aussie Blokes Are Ditching 8-Leg Multis For Day Trading
  3. A ‘Fuck You’ Attitude Is The Key To Success
Garry Lu
WORDS by
After stretching his legs with companies such as The Motley Fool and the odd marketing agency, Garry joined Boss Hunting in 2019 as a fully-fledged Content Specialist. In 2021, he was promoted to News Editor. Garry proudly retains a blue belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, black bruises from Muay Thai, as well as a black belt in all things pop culture. Drop him a line at [email protected]